Trial Objective
- Prosaro® PRO is a new foliar fungicide for Western Canada that combines three active ingredients to protect wheat, barley, oats, and triticale against leaf and head diseases in high-disease environments.
- Prosaro® PRO foliar fungicide contains tebuconazole (the fast-acting leaf disease specialist), prothioconazole (prolonged action for longer residual control), and fluopyram (a new group 7 active ingredient that provides fast-acting and residual protection for leaf and head diseases).
- The objective of these trials was to evaluate Prosaro® PRO foliar fungicide in wheat for yield and quality protection compared to an untreated check and a competitor fungicide at T3 application timing in wheat in 2020 and 2021.
Experiment/Trial Design
- Research Site Details:
- 53 locations throughout Western Canada from the Market Development Representative (MDR) and Market Development Agronomist (MDA) trial programs in 2020 and 2021.
Figure 1. Western Canada trial locations in 2020 (left) and 2021 (right).
- MDR trials were applied in a replicated strip format with Bayer-owned equipment.
- MDA trials were applied in a replicated strip format with grower equipment.
- Trial fields were evaluated for variability using field health imagery from Climate FieldView™. Only fields with relatively low variability across the trial area were used.
- All aspects of field management within the trial area were consistent except for the fungicide treatment.
- Trial Design:
- Fungicide treatments were applied according to the label at the optimal head timing (T3 – when 75% of the wheat heads on the main stem are fully emerged to when 50% of wheat heads on the main stem are flowering).
- Treatments included:
- Untreated check
- Prosaro® PRO foliar fungicide + NIS (non-ionic surfactant)
- Miravis® Ace fungicide + NIS
- Leaf disease assessments were conducted at the time of application and 10 to 14 days after application timing.
- Treatments were harvested and weighed with a weigh wagon to determine yield.
- At harvest, grain samples were taken from each treatment rep and evaluated for common grain quality parameters.
- Data Quality and Summary:
- Yield and grain quality data were assessed for quality by checking the overall trial CV (coefficient of variance) and the CV between reps for each trial location. Only trials with a CV of less than 10 were used in data summaries.
- A balanced data summary from the MDR and MDA programs in 2020 and 2021 was pulled to compare the yield and quality performance of Prosaro® PRO to the untreated check and competitor.
Understanding the Results
- Environmental Considerations:
- 2020 had generally good moisture conditions across the west. Above-average to average precipitation in Alberta and Northwest Saskatchewan. Average to below-average precipitation in Saskatchewan and Manitoba (Figure 2).
- Overall disease pressure in the trials was low to normal in 2020.
Figure 2. Percent of average precipitation across Western Canada in 2020. Permission to use map granted by Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada.
- 2021 was an extreme drought for much of the west (Figure 3).
- Overall disease pressure in the trials was nonexistent.
Figure 3. Percent of average precipitation across Western Canada in 2021. Permission to use map granted by Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada.
- Performance:
- The two-year summary of 53 trials shows there was a noticeable yield advantage for a fungicide application at the T3 timing in wheat compared to untreated.
- The untreated check averaged 61.6 bu/acre (4142.67 kg/hectare), the Prosaro® PRO foliar fungicide + NIS treatment averaged 65.6 bu/acre (4411.67 kg/hectare), and the Miravis® Ace fungicide + NIS treatment averaged 65.9 bu/acre (4431.85 kg/hectare) (Figure 4).
- The Prosaro® PRO foliar fungicide + NIS treatment and Miravis® Ace fungicide + NIS treatment had similar average yields (Figure 4).
Figure 4. Two-year (2020, 2021) average wheat yield comparison for fungicide use (53 trials in Western Canada).
- Fusarium was found in the grain samples from the 2020 trials.
- A fungicide treatment reduced the % FDK (Fusarium-damaged kernels) in the grain samples compared to the untreated check. However, the % FDK for the untreated check was low enough to fall under No. 1 Canadian Western Spring Wheat (CWRS) (Table 1). No grade improvements were gained from a fungicide treatment due to low overall disease pressure.
- The % FDK in the Prosaro® PRO foliar fungicide + NIS treatment sample and in the Miravis® Ace fungicide + NIS treatment sample were similar and less than the level found in the untreated check treatment sample (Figure 5).
- Not surprising, Fusarium was not found in the grain samples from the 2021 trials because of very low disease pressure due to the extreme drought.
Table 1. Percent of Fusarium-Infected Grain That Reduces Grade*
Grade Name |
Fusarium Damage Percent |
No. 1 CWRS |
0.3 |
No. 2 CWRS |
0.8 |
No. 3 CWRS |
1.5 |
CW Feed |
4.0 |
Grade, if specs for CW Feed not met |
Wheat, Sample CW Account
Fusarium Damage Over 10% - Wheat, Commercial Salvage |
*Adapted from Primary Grade Determinants Table for Canada Western Spring (CWRS) Wheat. Canadian Grain Commission Official Grain Grading Guide effective August 1, 2021. Permission granted for use by Craig Smith, Canadian Grain Commission/Government of Canada.
Figure 5. Average percent damaged kernels (FDK) from 22 Western Canada locations in 2020. Blue lines indicate CWRS grade levels.
Key Learnings
- A positive yield response in wheat could be seen from a Prosaro® PRO foliar fungicide T3 application compared to the untreated check in the two years (2020, 2021) under lower-than-normal precipitation and disease pressure.
- Assuming suggested prices of $6/bu for wheat and $5/acre for application cost, the fungicide application broke even.
- Prosaro® PRO foliar fungicide is a premium fungicide that is targeted towards average to above-average disease pressure fields. These trials showed Prosaro® PRO foliar fungicide has a positive effect on yield and quality even in drier, lower disease pressure years.
- We look forward to a more ‘normal’ precipitation year to show how Prosaro® PRO foliar fungicide protects against tough wheat leaf and head diseases.
Legal Statements
The information discussed in this report is from a multiple site, replicated demonstration. This informational piece is designed to report the results of this demonstration and is not intended to infer any confirmed trends. Please use this information accordingly.
Services and products offered by The Climate Corporation are subject to the customer agreeing to our Terms of Service. Our services provide estimates or recommendations based on models. These do not guarantee results. Before making financial, risk management and farming decisions, agronomists, commodities brokers and other service professionals should be consulted. More information at https://climatefieldview.ca/legal/disclaimer. FieldView® is a registered trademark of The Climate Corporation. Used under license. ALWAYS READ AND FOLLOW PESTICIDE LABEL DIRECTIONS. Performance may vary from location to location and from year to year, as local growing, soil and weather conditions may vary. Growers should evaluate data from multiple locations and years whenever possible and should consider the impacts of these conditions on the grower’s fields.
Bayer, Bayer Cross and Prosaro® are registered trademarks of Bayer Group. Used under license. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners. Bayer CropScience Inc. is a member of CropLife Canada. ©2022 Bayer Group. All rights reserved. 1711_23600